All posts by allthoughtsnosense

Unknown's avatar

About allthoughtsnosense

I have a lot of thoughts tumbling around upstairs, so I thought I might get them out somewhere. Maybe they'll make you laugh, help you, or give you some inspiration to write your own stuff. Either way, here's some of my idle ramblings.

Is AI content the end of creativity? Asking for a friend (and my soul)

I found myself at Barcelona airport recently, stuffing my face with spinach empanadas during my 5-hour layover. My attention drifted between Hell’s Kitchen compilations on YouTube, and people-watching the endless parade of travellers (we all do it – don’t lie). Among the fancily-clad executives in three-piece suits, and the vibrant, sunhat-and-sandal-wearing women, inevitably bracing for a week of liver abuse, something caught my eye. A moving picture inside the window of Ale-Hop. It was grotesque yet mesmerising, disturbing yet hypnotic. I couldn’t look away; it sucked my eyes out of their sockets until my feet compelled me towards it. I stood before it, wide-eyed, a half-eaten empanada in one hand. 

The screen showed people dancing in flower fields, wearing suits and sundresses adorned with daisies, roses, and countless blooms I couldn’t name. It was visually stunning, a blatant display of extravagance, luxury. But something looked… off. Beneath the cheesy smiles and awkward dancing, an unsettling quality lingered like dust in a still room. 

Was it the alien attractiveness of the models? The otherworldly perfection of their outfits? The flawless, idyllic fields? The ad oozed beauty, but it felt hollow; like I could knock on the screen and hear it echo. Then, it hit me like a train: as one dancer twirled, the top of her head morphed from a bunch of flowers into a mop of silver hair. The next scene, a younger woman in a stunning red dress spun, but her dress veered in the opposite direction before unnaturally snapping back to follow her. Physics-defying, frighteningly peculiar. 

This wasn’t real. The striking people, the ethereal field, the elegant clothes; they were all AI-generated. These people didn’t exist, nor did the flower field, nor those dresses and perfectly-tailored suits – they were the concoction of a computer, just pixels on a screen. 

Once upon a time, in a land far away, there lived a slew of artists who relied on one thing and one thing only: their own minds. They generated ideas, they crafted their own briefs, they wrote and produced their own art and content, they proofread it and edited it themselves. They brought their visions to life; designers, artists, writers, photographers, videographers, ad agencies – all had one thing in common: humans.

The world’s most creative, innovative, unique art was born from the minds of people

Creativity is the innate desire to explore the unknown, to expand the mind, to go places you’ve never been. Pushing the boundaries of what people have done before you is an inborn characteristic of an artist, it’s an instinct, and it’s part of the oneness of being human. From sculpting beauty with our bare hands to conjuring entire universes like Harry Potter or The Lord of the Rings from our imagination. Our big, beautiful brains give rise to the incredible, the incomprehensible, the sublime. 

There was a time when I believed humanity could only ascend; that our creative potential was limitless; that our ability to create, invent, forge, and shape the world how we see fit could only expand. And with technology, those possibilities seemed endless. We could build bigger and better things, use computers to check grammar and accelerate writing, automate what would otherwise take us hours. But now I can’t help but wonder: where are we?

AI is the 21st century’s venus flytrap: a fascinating, intriguing, captivating invention that lures in prey like moths to a flame. Yet it’s an unsuspecting snare – a sinkhole that can break down nature’s creations. Everywhere I look, I see AI-generated ads. And they’re not blatantly obvious. You have to scrutinise some ‘art’ to gauge whether it was churned out in ChatGPT in seconds, or whether a human being painstakingly crafted it with their own hands. It’s so convincing that I often catch myself admiring it; but the longer I look, the more unusual and peculiar it seems.

Crowd faces are distorted, like fragments of a bad dream you can’t wake up from. Hands are twisted, contorted, a surreal vision of unreality. The whole picture feels wrong, but you can’t pinpoint why. That’s AI. It’s not real. It’s not human, creative, or unique – it’s a regurgitation of existing art, stripped of its soul. AI takes what’s already been created, and it spews out a generic, cold version of it. Yet people are losing their minds about its possibilities. 

Every day on LinkedIn, I scroll past carousel posts filled with AI-generated ads for various brands. Sure, they’re visually appealing – at first glance. But look closer, and an aura of falseness rears its ugly head – a fuzzy mist that whispers not real. The background words are nonsensical, the headings overly polished, the entire composition beautiful but soulless. Half the content on LinkedIn is so flagrantly AI-made, undoubtedly never touched by a human hand. And it makes me sad. 

It’s all. The same. Shit. 

Generic, boring, overly-professional, robotic, always the same recurring bullet point and cookie-cutter structure: eye-catching hook, sweeping intro, bullet points, CTA. Someone please tell me: what’s the point in content creation if none of it is human? Are we doomed to a future of soulless, computer-generated babble because we’re too lazy to be creators anymore? Have we really become so complacent that innovation and originality no longer matter? 

Because here’s the truth: it’s impossible for AI to be original because everything it creates is based on pre-written, pre-made art. Humans create art: AI merely replicates it, vomiting out a generic, recycled version tailored to your prompts and inputs. It’s not original, it’s not unique – it’s secondhand. 

But the scariest part? People are ignoring the bigger picture. We’re literally letting computers do all our hard work for us. Students are AI-generating essays and homework, personal trainers are using ChatGPT for meal plan creation, people are AI-writing entire books. Does no one see the impact this will have on human intelligence? We’re shifting our creativity, intellect, and critical thinking to an auto-generator, outsourcing it to a machine. We’re no longer sitting with our own thoughts and basking in the glory of what it means to be human. We’ve collectively stopped caring about honing our own skills – and no one seems concerned.  

There’s nothing as irreplaceable as the human touch: storytelling, humour, empathy, language nuances – AI can’t replicate that. Readers connect with authentic voices and lived experiences; AI has never lived, so how can it be relatable? Sure, it’s useful for idea generation, data summaries, SEO research, and proofreading; shit, it even helped me proofread this article. But can it truly be creative? Can it infuse content with emotional depth, humour, brand voice, soul? 

For a long time I feared how AI would impact the job market. Artists, videographers, photographers, graphic designers, marketers, and of course, copywriters are all slowly being replaced by faster, cheaper automated assistants.

But instead of fearing or outright hating AI, I’ve chosen to work with it.

I still don’t believe in any way, shape, or form, that it should replace humans or be used for content creation, but it can work with humans. It can handle the repetitive, mundane tasks that notoriously take hours, it can generate ideas, draft outlines, suggest edits, proofread, or even streamline research when Google is too cluttered with ads to be objective.

AI can be leveraged without being relied upon; it’s a tool, not a crutch. It’s a way to enhance productivity without sacrificing authenticity, unlike the (cough lazy cough) reliance too many companies have embraced. 

Offended? Maybe you won’t like what I’ve said. That’s fine. A blog’s purpose is to speak your mind, after all. I’m not afraid of AI. I’m just sick of it.

What’s your hot take?

2 responses to “Is AI content the end of creativity? Asking for a friend (and my soul)”

  1. juliannepickard Avatar

    Such an interesting topic and 100% agree with all of this!!

    Like

  2. artisanmaximumd4923f1c53 Avatar
    artisanmaximumd4923f1c53

    I sooo agree AI should be used as a tool and not just replace human creativity entirely. Fully AI generated art always feels so wrong 😬

    Like

Leave a comment

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

Make a one-time donation

Make a monthly donation

Make a yearly donation

Choose an amount

€5.00
€15.00
€100.00
€5.00
€15.00
€100.00
€5.00
€15.00
€100.00

Or enter a custom amount


Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly

What scrubbing toilets taught me about writing

It was a busy summer Sunday, and a customer was complaining about an offensive stench from the upstairs bathroom. Just what I need, I thought to myself, as I balanced two hot plates of fish and chips on my left arm and what felt like a 5kg beef and Guinness pie in my right hand, my fingers slipping slowly from the plate’s edge as my tendons strained against the weight. I’ll check it out right away, I told the flustered customer with a forced smile, as I bustled downstairs to deliver my food (and rage) to the waiting diners. 

I trudged back upstairs, questioning whether this alleged horror warranted nearly breaking my fingers and tumbling down the stairs in a tidal wave of marrowfat peas and beef gravy. Then I smelled it. I had barely even touched the door when I knew – Susan, I take it all back, you were right. It was offensive. So offensive, I briefly considered throwing my t-shirt at my manager and quitting right then and there. But mama didn’t raise a quitter. I gritted my teeth and stepped over the threshold into no-man’s-land, into certain death. My eyes watered. My knees buckled. The three-bean chili I had for lunch staged a violent protest, and I went straight back out again. 

Without getting too graphic, putting my hand into a black sack and fishing out what can only be described as a premature baby from the women’s toilets, with barely a flimsy bit of plastic between me and certain chaos, was not how I envisioned spending my life. I wanted more. I wanted to be my own boss, and not the kind that makes food handlers play plumbing roulette with their bare hands. 

At the time, I was a waitress and bartender at a busy Irish pub in the heart of a tourist town in Dublin (name withheld to protect its bathroom’s honour). I spent most of my time talking to people, whether at their tables or behind the bar, and learned a lot about human nature and psychology. For example, a tourist will order a Guinness, blissfully unaware that the half-filled pint settling on the drip tray isn’t theirs yet, and take it back to their table, lips hovering dangerously close to the brim of an underdeveloped pint. Meanwhile, old men will send their pints back if they’re not in the right glass, which, conversely, I rightly agree with. If my whiskey shows up in anything other than a tumbler, it’s going straight back to the bar. 

People will talk about anything when they think the bartender isn’t listening. But spoiler alert: we’re always listening. Not because we necessarily give a shit. There’s simply not much else to do between pulling pints and waiting for Guinness to settle.

There’s a lot to be learned about human nature by opening your ears and paying attention to pub-goers. That lingering aura of Guinness farts didn’t just appear from nowhere. That’s Johnny, three seats from the end of the bar, cognitively dissonant of the biological warfare he’s been unleashing for the last hour and a half. And the girl four seats down, wrapped around the fella she met last night, she’s going out with the guy who works in the pub up the road. But that’s none of my business. None at all. 

Being a bartender is about reading the room: who’s up for a chat? Who just wants to drink in silence? Who’s cheating? Which ones have flatulence problems? That older gentleman who insists on ordering only from me? Probably just lonely. The lady who tips me a euro for every drink I bring her might miss her daughter who just moved away. The girl who’s cheating on her boyfriend might be in an open relationship. You don’t know people’s stories, but you adapt to their demeanour. Pick your battles: if they’re quiet, don’t force the conversation. If they’re chatty, humour them. It’s not rocket science.

Psychology comes into it a lot more than you’d expect; copywriting is no different. 

Choosing your audience is the first part of marketing – knowing who you’re talking to and what they want, how to use language so they understand complex concepts without hurting their brains. You’re not barking your product at them or pouring your service down their throat in the hopes that they’ll swallow at least some of it; you’re just talking to them.

Copy isn’t about convincing them of something or forcing a sale, it’s about starting a conversation. Getting someone to click into your content is the first battle, but getting them to read all the way to the end? That’s as hard as cleaning out a Sunday afternoon toilet with nothing but a plastic bag and a set of rosary beads. 

You spend your life as a young adult being told the same spiel: go to college, get a degree, land a good job or you’ll never get where you want in life. Well, here I am, pushing 30 with two degrees and a decade of work experience on my back, and am I where I want to be? Absolutely not. You can do everything by the book and still end up in your late 20s, completely lost. But that doesn’t mean you’re not learning from the experiences you’ve had.

Getting screamed at by secondary school teachers, failing college exams, writing a thesis, scrubbing toilets, getting bossed around and treated like a cadet in boot camp for a poorly wiped table, being told to fuck off by drunken patrons, doing countless interviews for roles you’re more than qualified for and getting nothing but rejections, handling difficult customers whose sole purpose in life is ruining yours; none of it is fun.

None of it is futile. It teaches patience, adaptability, problem solving, and quick thinking. And that’s exactly what every good writer needs to have. 

You might be wondering – what the hell do fish and chips, cheating girlfriends, Guinness farts and toilet cleaning have to do with writing? Everything is writing. I wanted more than just a job, I wanted a vocation. Something that forced me to search the depths of my soul for the very words I couldn’t find in my own head. I wanted something with meaning, something with life. Something where I could write what I was thinking and have people relate to me.

Tell an American tourist the life story of Jameson and suddenly, they’re a whiskey drinker for life. Explain why Guinness is pulled differently and watch them stare wide-eyed as it settles from brown to black. Vent to the flirty old man at the bar about the bad customer you just had and he’ll promise to knock them out next time he sees them. Write an article about digital transformation shaping software and fintech businesses? Same thing.

It’s all storytelling. It’s all writing. 

Storytelling is nothing without creativity. But what’s that without pressure? Some of my best writing has come from sheer, unadulterated panic. I had three months to write my thesis; how much do you think got done in the two weeks before submission? A LOT (let’s keep that between us and not my thesis supervisor). Work ethic and creativity go hand-in-hand, and pressure is the warm hug holding them together.

Take bartending: someone asks you to make them a cocktail, bartender’s choice. Here you are, seven different types of fruit in front of you, two kinds of ice, a wall of spirits, and a fridge full of juice. Your brain cells are rubbing together like they’re huddling for warmth in a blizzard.

It’s the same with copywriting: deadlines and constraints force innovation. You’d be amazed by what you create when you dive head-first into it. Don’t hesitate, don’t hold your breath: just go for it. 

What’s your worst grunt-work story?

6–8 minutes

One-Time
Monthly
Yearly

Make a one-time donation

Make a monthly donation

Make a yearly donation

Choose an amount

€5.00
€15.00
€100.00
€5.00
€15.00
€100.00
€5.00
€15.00
€100.00

Or enter a custom amount


Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

Your contribution is appreciated.

DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly